🤔 Grammar · Commonly Confused Words
Been vs Gone
Did they come back, or are they still away? Learn been and gone with the film The Wild Robot.
Grammar › Commonly Confused Words › Been vs Gone
The rule in one sentenceUse been when the person went and came back. Use gone when the person went and is still there.
About the film
The Wild Robot is a film from 2024. Roz is a robot. She has been to every part of a wild island. The geese have gone south for the winter. Brightbill, a young goose, has gone with them. Roz waits for him.
What is the difference?
Both words go after have or has. Both talk about going somewhere. The big question is: is the person here now?
Been means the person went and came back. The trip is finished. Roz is here now:
Gone means the person went and is still there. They are not here now:
Put them side by side:
People say the short form. Learn both:
Roz has been to the forest. (she is back) Roz has gone to the forest. (she is still there)
Same place. One word changes. Ask: is Roz here now?
Visual guide
Teacher Teddy’s illustrated guide to this rule is being drawn — the full swipe-through infographic will appear here soon.
How to make it
Been — went and came back
Roz has been to the beach.
Roz hasn’t been to the cold north.
haven’t / hasn’t + beenHas she been to the cave?
Have / Has + person + beenGone — went and is still there
Brightbill has gone south.
Fink hasn’t gone with the geese.
haven’t / hasn’t + goneHas Brightbill gone already?
Have / Has + person + goneWhen to use each one
Been — the person is back
Gone — the person is away
Words that help: been or gone?
Some words tell you which one to use.
Been
Gone
Common mistakes
❌ Roz has gone to the beach. Now she is home.
✅ Roz has been to the beach. Now she is home.
She is home now. She came back → been.
❌ The geese have been south. The island is empty.
✅ The geese have gone south. The island is empty.
The geese are not here. They are still away → gone.
❌ Have you ever gone to a wild island?
✅ Have you ever been to a wild island?
“Ever” asks about your life. You went and came back → been.
❌ Where is Fink? He has been out.
✅ Where is Fink? He has gone out.
Fink is not here now → gone.
One more thing
This part is a little harder. You can come back to it later.
“Gone” can mean “not here any more”. You do not always need a place after it. The winter is gone. The food is gone. This means it is finished, or not here now.
✅ “The geese are gone. The island is quiet.”
Practice: been or gone?
Eight questions. Choose one word. You get the answer, and why.
1. Roz has ___ to the beach many times. She is at home now.
She went and came back → been.
2. Brightbill has ___ south with the geese. He is not here.
He is still away → gone.
3. Has Roz ever ___ to the top of the island?
“Ever” asks about a trip and back → been.
4. Fink has ___ to the forest. Come back later.
He is still in the forest → gone.
5. The geese have ___ away for the winter. The island is quiet.
They are still away → gone.
6. Pinktail has ___ to the river twice today.
“Twice” means two trips and back → been.
7. Where is Roz? She has ___ to find food.
She is not here now → gone.
8. I have never ___ to a cold island.
“Never” talks about your life → been.
Your turn
Choose a place. Then listen to your sentence.
Every word here is correct. Roz is back. Brightbill is still away. Say it out loud too!
Keep going
More lessons
Practise listening at your level
Hear this grammar used for real — Beginner English listening practice. Full movie reviews in slow, clear English, levelled for Beginner learners. One new episode every week, free, with a transcript. BeginnerFree playlistWatch on YouTube