💽 Plot & how the story is told

Let’s start with the story. As her twenty-third birthday gets closer, Kara Zor-El spends her time travelling from party to party across the galaxy, with her dog Krypto by her side. Her cousin keeps calling her, hoping she’ll finally visit him on Earth, but Kara keeps ignoring him.

Kara’s cousin is Kal-El — better known to most viewers as Superman — but this film is entirely her own story, not his.

Before we go further into the plot, it’s worth understanding why Kara behaves this way. She isn’t avoiding her cousin because she dislikes him. She’s avoiding the version of herself that everyone expects her to be. Being compared constantly to Superman, a calm, selfless, endlessly patient hero, has pushed Kara toward the opposite: reckless, distracted, and determined to live entirely on her own terms.

While travelling, Kara meets a young alien girl named Ruthye, whose father has just been killed. Ruthye wants revenge, and she asks Kara for help finding the man responsible.

At first, Kara says no. She has no interest in getting involved in someone else’s fight.

Kara and Ruthye set off together, joined along the way by Lobo, a rough, dangerous alien bounty hunter with his own reasons for getting involved.

Lobo deserves a little more attention here, because he’s a big part of why this film feels so different from a typical superhero story. He’s loud, violent, frequently played for comedy, and completely uninterested in being anyone’s role model. And yet, scene by scene, he becomes something closer to found family for Kara and Ruthye than either of them expects.

The film structures their journey almost like a space western: travelling from world to world, picking up clues about Krem’s whereabouts, and encountering increasingly strange allies and enemies along the way. Each stop reveals a little more about who Ruthye’s father was, and why Krem wanted him dead in the first place.

Ruthye herself is written as young, sharp, and completely fixed on one goal. She isn’t interested in Kara’s fame or her powers — she’s interested in finding the person responsible for her father’s death, and she pushes Kara to stay focused on that same goal, even when Kara is tempted to get distracted.

As the journey continues, Kara starts to change. The reckless, distracted party girl from the film’s opening slowly gives way to someone genuinely invested in seeing this mission through — not because she’s told to, but because she’s chosen to.

Now, let’s talk about how this story is told. This isn’t a traditional cape story. Critics have described it as more of an “anti-hero” tale, following Kara on a journey that looks more like a revenge story than a classic save-the-world adventure.

The tone throughout is rougher and more chaotic than a typical superhero film, closer in spirit to a story about a reluctant traveller pulled into someone else’s mission than a polished team-up movie. The comic it’s based on is often compared to True Grit, and that comparison shows up clearly on screen: an experienced, weathered guide, a determined young companion, and a journey defined by grief and justice rather than spectacle for its own sake.

By the end of the film, Kara has to decide how far she’s willing to go for justice — for Ruthye, for her dog, and, in her own complicated way, for herself. Without spoiling exactly how the mission ends, the film closes by asking what Kara actually owes to the people around her, now that she’s finally let herself care about something again.

📖 Vocabulary spotlight

Alongside our grammar focus, this episode also has five vocabulary words for you — some pulled from how critics and commentators have actually described this film, and some straight from the story itself.

💬 Online discussion

Now let’s look at what critics and audiences have been saying about Supergirl.

One consistent point of praise, even among more critical reviews, is Milly Alcock’s performance. Many critics who otherwise disliked parts of the film still singled out her performance as a genuine highlight, describing her as capturing both Kara’s recklessness and her underlying grief convincingly.

Jason Momoa’s Lobo has also been a frequent talking point. Audiences and critics alike have enjoyed his performance, with many reviews calling him one of the most purely entertaining parts of the entire film.

Fans of the original comic have weighed in too, with plenty of online discussion comparing the film directly to Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow. Reactions here have generally been positive, with many longtime readers feeling the film captured the comic’s unusual, True Grit-inspired tone reasonably faithfully.

Something similar to the critical divide happened at the box office. The film opened relatively softly in cinemas, finishing behind Toy Story 5 in its second weekend, against a large production budget.

This gap between its theatrical performance and its streaming success has become one of the most discussed angles in coverage of the film, with many commentators using it as a case study for how a film’s opening weekend doesn’t always predict how audiences end up feeling about it in the long run.

There’s also been broader online discussion about what this film means for future DC projects featuring these characters, with plenty of speculation about whether its more unconventional, character-driven approach will influence how similar stories get told going forward.

Collapse transcript ↑